Music History as Part of a Jazz Curriculum

Music History. No two words seem to inspire more dread in music students than these. The battery of music history courses can often be among the most challenging and least rewarding in undergraduate and graduate curriculums alike. Among jazz students these courses are often more problematic because they require prolonged study of material only tacitly related to jazz topics. This is compounded by a general attitude among musicology professors that our music--jazz--does not deserve as close scrutiny as say, the morality plays of Hildegard Von Bingen, the motets of Monteverdi, or the topics of alternity in nineteenth century Europe. (This is changing among many younger musicologists, but this change of attitute is not in evidence in most curriculums.)
            Perhaps the most frustrating aspect of college musicology courses is the expectation that jazz musicians not only master the history and analysis of western music as described above, but also demonstrate an equal—preferably greater—grasp on jazz research topics as well. This seems like a huge double standard when compared with classical music students. This arrangement essentially doubles the musicological responsibilities of the jazz student.
            Why do we have to take classical history courses? Knowledge of Montiverdi or HVB will not help us play II-Vs better, they won't help us in our interpretation of Body and Soul or Cherokee, they aren't going to help our high notes. As a trombone professor once told me: "Music history can't teach you shit about playing in the upper register!" So why should we be required to know this material?
            Consider our counterparts in performance tracks: those who study strings, voice, piano or other classical musics exclusively. These students progress through traditional musicology courses alongside jazz students. If a musicology program is effective, it would be fair to say that a jazz student and a classical student who progress through the same musicological curriculum would have the same grasp of the topics covered. Upon completion of this program, both students should be able critically examine music from all periods covered in the course. (More likely they forget it all immediately after completion if the course, but that is a topic for a different time.)
            It is here where the advantage goes to the jazz student. Classical training does a great job preparing students to engage in the music of Beethoven, Brahms, Mahler or Stravinsky. It does a poor job in teaching students how to engage in all music. For example, ask a classically trained student to discuss the evolution of opera and he or she will happily expound on Peri, Montiverdi, Gluck, and a host of other important operatic players. Now ask the same student on their thoughts regarding the birth of bebop or the evolution of R&B and Rock and Roll during the mid twentieth century, and he or she will be suddenly silent. Classical training does not prepare students to deal outside of the classical realm. (Many might take issue on this point as jazz and other popular musics are becoming taught more at universities, however these courses are typically electives, not requirements. Additionally I have my own personal reservations on the integrity of many of these courses when compared with the intensity of traditional musicology courses.) In short, the classical student has become limited by education.
            This is not true for the jazz student. The study of jazz gives the student a skill set with which to study all forms of popular music in the twentieth and twenty first centuries. (It could also be argued that this same skill set could be used to study all music. I mean come on, just because JS Bach drove a horse and buggy to work in the eighteenth century doesn’t mean we should when we have perfectly good Ferraries to zip around in. But that’s a conversation for a different time.) In addition, because of the pesky musicology degree requirements, the jazz student just as qualified to engage in the discussion and in many cases the performance of classical music.
            From this perspective we must ask ourselves, who is receiving the best education? In the modern music world there is no such thing as someone who only plays one kind of music, when that phone rings we want our students to be able to say yes to any performance or teaching opportunity regardless of what degree was earned. That being the case, it is the jazz degree and the seemingly endless arsenal of classical musicology courses that is the best at preparing the student for the real world.  We should not complain about our classical training, it prepares us for any professional or academic situation. We should be more concerned about our classical colleagues who proceed through the same degrees as us, pick up the same student loans as us, yet only receive half the education. It is from these students where the real outcry should be heard. So this fall as the next round of musicology survey courses begin, instead of moaning about how unfair it is to be a jazz student studying Bach Cantatas, we should ask ourselves; who is receiving the better education: the classical student, or the jazz student?
 

29 comments

  • Allan
    Allan America
    Genuine music downloads are winding up being dynamically more prominent by virtue of the move of the MP3 player. I love to peruse [url=https://www.proessaywriting.com/coursework/]coursework writing[/url] reviews to transform into a productive understudy as the genuine change made purchasing lawful music downloads a through and through requirement for specific individuals. Individuals no longer feel its alright to get music continually particularly with the danger of abuse.

    Genuine music downloads are winding up being dynamically more prominent by virtue of the move of the MP3 player. I love to peruse coursework writing reviews to transform into a productive understudy as the genuine change made purchasing lawful music downloads a through and through requirement for specific individuals. Individuals no longer feel its alright to get music continually particularly with the danger of abuse.

  • Ciara Lee
    Ciara Lee Hollywood
    I guess, jazz curriculum is so fun to take especially if you are the type of person who loves music! Indeed, music history should be part of it. Being under the Conservatory of Music is hard. There are some of my friends under the program and I can just imagine their struggles. Before they need [url=https://uk.bestessays.com/academic-writing-help.html]academic writing help[/url] and I am just happy to see that I was able to help them all throughout and I gave my support to them.

    I guess, jazz curriculum is so fun to take especially if you are the type of person who loves music! Indeed, music history should be part of it. Being under the Conservatory of Music is hard. There are some of my friends under the program and I can just imagine their struggles. Before they need academic writing help and I am just happy to see that I was able to help them all throughout and I gave my support to them.

  • Jacky
    Jacky United States
    [url=https://www.danezon.com/product/mens-brown-cafe-racer-leather-jacket/]Café Racer Leather Jacket [/url]
  • Rob Schubert
    Rob Schubert
    I see that you have a lot of difficulties with your music sometimes and actually you don't know what to do. Hovewer, you can get topresume at www.topresumewritingservices.com and start living the best life of a well-paid specialist! It could be the last possibility in your life to establish the sustainable background after your music career ending.

    I see that you have a lot of difficulties with your music sometimes and actually you don't know what to do. Hovewer, you can get topresume at www.topresumewritingservices.com and start living the best life of a well-paid specialist! It could be the last possibility in your life to establish the sustainable background after your music career ending.

  • shawn kemp
    shawn kemp
    That is one of the main reasons that I am very much interested in knowing the history of the things. As most of the time their names are greatly related with their history. write my paper for me Also sometimes you can realize the importance of the thing just by knowing its name like this one here shows its importance by its name that is “cure all”.

    That is one of the main reasons that I am very much interested in knowing the history of the things. As most of the time their names are greatly related with their history. write my paper for me Also sometimes you can realize the importance of the thing just by knowing its name like this one here shows its importance by its name that is “cure all”.

  • shawn kemp
    shawn kemp
    This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read your all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. learndash customization Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have ma

    This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read your all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. learndash customization Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have ma

  • shawn kemp
    shawn kemp
    I will always let you and your words become part of my day because you never know how much you make my day happier and more complete. There are even times when I feel so down but assignment writing help I will feel better right after checking your blogs. You have made me feel so good about myself all the time and please know that I do appreciate everything that you have

    I will always let you and your words become part of my day because you never know how much you make my day happier and more complete. There are even times when I feel so down but assignment writing help I will feel better right after checking your blogs. You have made me feel so good about myself all the time and please know that I do appreciate everything that you have

  • shawn kemp
    shawn kemp
    Thanks for such wonderful blog that looks pretty different, I would suggest you please make a proper plan for your blog and start professional blogging as a career, One day you would be help with essay helper smart enough to earn some money, wishing you a best of luck my friend, Thanks a lot for your nice support and love.

    Thanks for such wonderful blog that looks pretty different, I would suggest you please make a proper plan for your blog and start professional blogging as a career, One day you would be help with essay helper smart enough to earn some money, wishing you a best of luck my friend, Thanks a lot for your nice support and love.

  • shawn kemp
    shawn kemp
    I want to say that is one of the top notch posts that i've perused in all my existence. the whole thing right here is certainly remarkable. I couldn't have requested a highly improved put up than this. . help with assignment helper am capable of bookmark your internet web site and advocate to all my pals

    I want to say that is one of the top notch posts that i've perused in all my existence. the whole thing right here is certainly remarkable. I couldn't have requested a highly improved put up than this. . help with assignment helper am capable of bookmark your internet web site and advocate to all my pals

  • Ethan henry
    Ethan henry UAS
    Thank you so much for sharing such a great and [url=https://www.topcelebrityjackets.com/Star-wars-luke-skywalker-(mark%20hamill)-yellow-jacket]Mark Hamill Jacket[/url] knowledgeable blog. Thanks!

    Thank you so much for sharing such a great and Mark Hamill Jacket knowledgeable blog. Thanks!

  • Charles Malone
    Charles Malone Germany
    [Url=https://www.jacketpop.com/product/fast-and-furious-9-jakob-toretto-blazer.html] Jakob Toretto Jacket [/Url]
  • Emma Sheppard
    Emma Sheppard USA
    the best life of a well-paid specialist! It could be the last possibility in your life to establish the sustainable background after your music career ending. [url=https://techcompetitor.com/polina-sitnova/]Polina Sitnova[/url]

    the best life of a well-paid specialist! It could be the last possibility in your life to establish the sustainable background after your music career ending. Polina Sitnova

  • Evie Pickering
    Evie Pickering USA
    dread in music students than these. The battery of music history courses can often be among the most challenging and least rewarding in undergraduate and graduate curriculums alike [url=https://techloly.com/erik-per-sullivan/]Erik Per Sullivan Net Worth[/url]

    dread in music students than these. The battery of music history courses can often be among the most challenging and least rewarding in undergraduate and graduate curriculums alike Erik Per Sullivan Net Worth

  • coffee roasters dubai
    coffee roasters dubai UAE
    That is one of the main reasons that I am very much interested in knowing the history of jazz [url=https://emiraticoffee.com/]coffee roasters dubai[/url]

    That is one of the main reasons that I am very much interested in knowing the history of jazz coffee roasters dubai

  • Demolition and Excavation Contractor
    Demolition and Excavation Contractor USA
    Thank you so much for sharing [url=http://roadbridge.ca/]Demolition and Excavation Contractor[/url]

    Thank you so much for sharing Demolition and Excavation Contractor

  • Tank Cleaning Houston
    Tank Cleaning Houston USA
    study of jazz gives the student a skill set with which to study all forms of popular music [url=https://hastencleanse.com/]Tank Cleaning Houston[/url]

    study of jazz gives the student a skill set with which to study all forms of popular music Tank Cleaning Houston

  • sandra
    sandra United States
    I am so interested in knowing the history of the jazz curriculum. I am glad to see that I feel better after reading your [url=https://www.360ghostwriting.com/self-publishing]Best Self-Publishing Companies[/url] blog it's a very informative post.

    I am so interested in knowing the history of the jazz curriculum. I am glad to see that I feel better after reading your Best Self-Publishing Companies blog it's a very informative post.

  • yoursadvice
    yoursadvice American Samoa
    You're a brilliant content writer and I wish that i can see the best of you in future too. As you all know that there are many Best Legit Survey Sites of 2021 which provides you the rewards for surveys and we comes in that list only. Become our respondent now, quickly sign up on the website. https://www.yoursadvice.info


    You're a brilliant content writer and I wish that i can see the best of you in future too. As you all know that there are many Best Legit Survey Sites of 2021 which provides you the rewards for surveys and we comes in that list only. Become our respondent now, quickly sign up on the website. https://www.yoursadvice.info

  • Randy walison
    Randy walison United Kingdom
    I appreciate your work I think this is your own music group and you are the head of it. For this, I am willing to share one thing with you [url=https://www.unwedhousewifeblog.com/easy-sushi-pie-recipe.html]What Ingredients Do I Need To Make Sushi Pie At Home?[/url] in which you will do happy when you will see it.

    I appreciate your work I think this is your own music group and you are the head of it. For this, I am willing to share one thing with you What Ingredients Do I Need To Make Sushi Pie At Home? in which you will do happy when you will see it.

  • Fairy
    Fairy Micheal
    The Journal of the Music Education Research Committee provides a platform for anyone interested in music education to visit contemporary research. [url=https://www.ghostwritingfounder.com/book-writing/]book writing services[/url] sai dthat the announcement includes current research and comments interested in the international music industry.

    The Journal of the Music Education Research Committee provides a platform for anyone interested in music education to visit contemporary research. book writing services sai dthat the announcement includes current research and comments interested in the international music industry.

  • Gordon
    Gordon USA
    Amazing piece! I'll bookmark this and will share it to a friend. [url=https://www.crimescenecleanuptx.com/austin.html]Suicide Cleanup in Austin, TX[/url]

    Amazing piece! I'll bookmark this and will share it to a friend. Suicide Cleanup in Austin, TX

  • Nanncy
    Nanncy USA
    great content I must appreciate the writer of this website I had suffered from this kind of problem. but then my friend suggest I hire the services of [url=https://www.visionarywebdesigns.com/]Visionary web designs[/url] which turned to be a miracle for my website and help to make it SEO friendly.

    great content I must appreciate the writer of this website I had suffered from this kind of problem. but then my friend suggest I hire the services of Visionary web designs which turned to be a miracle for my website and help to make it SEO friendly.

  • sonu
    sonu Germany
    I like your blog because you always motivate youth who try to make their career in the music industry. I am glad to know about your and last one more thing your songs are good and provide peace of mind. Recently I start watching an Indian webs series called Kota factory Season 2. if you don't know about it then get the information from [URL=https://indiamemetemplates.blogspot.com/2021/09/kota-factory-season-2-meme-templates.html]Kota Factory season 2 meme templates[/URL]. This is an awesome web series.

    I like your blog because you always motivate youth who try to make their career in the music industry. I am glad to know about your and last one more thing your songs are good and provide peace of mind. Recently I start watching an Indian webs series called Kota factory Season 2. if you don't know about it then get the information from Kota Factory season 2 meme templates. This is an awesome web series.

  • Tyler
    Tyler United Kingdom
    Thanks for sharing this amazing post. In need of the best [url=https://www.gripelectric.net/]emergency electrician[/url] in the UK turn out to GripElectric for all-electric services at a cheap price. NO CALL OUT CHARGE - When ever your electricity or power is gone or your fuse box / consumer box is tripping / sockets not working / lights tripping / fuse box/consumer unit is blowing off give us a call our team of emergency electricians who are local in your area and near you are available all over the week on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday 24 hour a day 365 days a year

    Thanks for sharing this amazing post. In need of the best emergency electrician in the UK turn out to GripElectric for all-electric services at a cheap price. NO CALL OUT CHARGE - When ever your electricity or power is gone or your fuse box / consumer box is tripping / sockets not working / lights tripping / fuse box/consumer unit is blowing off give us a call our team of emergency electricians who are local in your area and near you are available all over the week on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday 24 hour a day 365 days a year

  • Malia Wilson
    Malia Wilson America
    Amazing piece! I'll bookmark this and will share it with a friend. Have you great lighting and shadow effects on your Minecraft game? then I know one blog about the shaders. give it once, tell me how it is. https://startupxplore.com/en/person/minecraft-shaders

    Amazing piece! I'll bookmark this and will share it with a friend. Have you great lighting and shadow effects on your Minecraft game? then I know one blog about the shaders. give it once, tell me how it is. https://startupxplore.com/en/person/minecraft-shaders

  • Frank Fort
    Frank Fort america
    This article really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. If you love to play games Install Xpadder V5.7 Controller is the best software to enhance your gaming experience. Click Here: https://www.colourinyourlife.com.au/members/install-xpadder/profile/

    This article really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. If you love to play games Install Xpadder V5.7 Controller is the best software to enhance your gaming experience.
    Click Here: https://www.colourinyourlife.com.au/members/install-xpadder/profile/

  • Frank Fort
    Frank Fort america
    This article really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. If you love to play games Install Xpadder V5.7 Controller is the best software to enhance your gaming experience. Click Here: https://www.colourinyourlife.com.au/members/install-xpadder/profile/

    This article really contains lot more information about This Topic. We have read all the information some points are also good and some usually are awesome. If you love to play games Install Xpadder V5.7 Controller is the best software to enhance your gaming experience.
    Click Here: https://www.colourinyourlife.com.au/members/install-xpadder/profile/

  • Aliena Lennon
    Aliena Lennon USA
    Well done information. Searching for 100% safe software to use and doesn’t ask for any paid subscriptions. Then go and download KMSPico. And activate the Microsoft products in your system. https://afreetooltoactivatealifetimeus.splashthat.com/

    Well done information. Searching for 100% safe software to use and doesn’t ask for any paid subscriptions. Then go and download KMSPico. And activate the Microsoft products in your system. https://afreetooltoactivatealifetimeus.splashthat.com/

Add comment